This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, please read my disclosure policy.

21 Best Drugstore Eye Makeup Removers | Review

Eye makeup remover is an ally of unconditional cosmetic care. Its choice should not, therefore, be made at random.

Your eyelids may tend to become irritated or have an allergy to certain makeup removers. So, you should definitely choose one that is both gentle and soothing to your sensitive eyes.

Wearing waterproof makeup or mascara also involves choosing a good quality makeup remover to maintain and protect the sensitive area around the eyes.

However, the use of simple make-up removing wipes can be detrimental to your optical health. You will therefore need to carefully sort out the best eye makeup remover to use with this guide.

Which Is The Best Eye Makeup Remover?

Each type of makeup remover has its own properties. A makeup remover that is used to clean waterproof makeup must, for example, have excellent washing power to remove it without attacking the fragile skin of your eyelids.

The best choice of makeup remover should also take into account the sensitivity of your eyes.

Buying a cheap, inappropriate, or inexpensive makeup remover puts you at a number of risks. At worst, it could even lead to the loss of your eyelashes.

Also Read:

The 21 Best Drugstore Eye Makeup Removers To Use

1. Solimo Eye Makeup Remover, Removes Waterproof Mascara – Dermatologist Tested

2. Almay Longwear & Waterproof Eye Makeup Pads – Hypoallergenic

3. Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Makeup Remover & Cleanser for Sensitive Eyes

4. L’Oreal Clean Artiste Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

5. Lancome Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

6. Burt’s Bees Eye Makeup Remover Pads

7. Rimmel Just Let It Go Eye Make-Up Remover

8. Marcelle Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads

9. Klorane Soothing Eye Make-up Remover

10. Garnier Skin Naturals Simply Essentials 2 in 1 Make-up Remover

11. AHAVA Eye Make-up Remover

12. Eau Thermale Avene Micellar Lotion Cleansing Water, Toner, Make-up Remover

13. Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover For Lids, Lashes, and Lips

14. Olay Daily Facials Soap-Free Eye Area Makeup Remover

15. La Roche-Posay Micellar Cleansing Water and Makeup Remover

16. Bi Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

17. Brooklyn Botany Camellia Wonder Oi

18. Neutrogena Hydrating Eye Makeup Remover Lotion

19. Natural Eye & Face Makeup Remover – Oil Free

20. Micellar Makeup Eye Remover Pads

21. Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover

Benefits Of Using A Make-Up Remover For The Eye Area

You may be wondering about the value of applying a specific makeup remover to clean the area around the eyes when you already have a face makeup remover.

Know that this area is particularly fragile and sensitive. It is therefore possible that your current makeup remover cannot really adapt to the requirements of your eyelids.

This may be because the skin on your face does not display the same sensitivity as the skin on your eyelids. In most cases, and also depending on the type of makeup you apply regularly, the eye area may also be more difficult to remove.

Better prevention against wrinkles and spots

Makeup around the eyes uses a variety of cosmetics. This is the case in particular with eyeliner, mascara, and eye shadow.

These products must be applied over a base coat that must accommodate various types of makeup funds: foundations, BB cream, loose powder, etc.

Since most of these makeups are thick, waterproof, and long-wearing, it is not obvious that you can clean them off with just a makeup remover.

In addition, it could promote the appearance of wrinkles and spots. This is why you should opt for a gentle make-up removal which may be more effective and less risky for your eyes and eyelids.

How To Choose A Makeup Remover For Your Eyes?

Your eyelids do not necessarily react the same way as those of others to contact with a specific makeup remover.

This could be perfectly explained by the fact that your eyes and eyelids do not display the same sensitivity or tolerance to makeup removers that other people use. This is a good reason to choose your makeup remover.

However, it is not always necessary to favor a high-end brand, because that does not entirely remedy your concern.

In case you buy an inappropriate makeup remover, it will not be of any use to you despite being of very good quality. Conversely, the purchase of a cheap makeup remover is extremely perilous.

It is therefore important that you learn more about a number of characteristics to form an opinion on the best choice of makeup remover to adopt.

Buying a makeup remover at the best value for money cannot be improvised. You must absolutely refer to different criteria to be sure not to make a mistake.

1. The choice of the formula adapted to the requirements of your eyelids

These makeup removers have at least three major variations of formulas namely: micellar water, cleansing oil, and cleansing milk. All of these formulas do not necessarily meet the requirements of your eyelids. This is why you must be careful to choose the one that will best meet your needs.

Makeup removers available in liquid form are the most convenient and gentle to apply. Micellar water is a gentle cleanser that consists of micelles.

These are responsible for isolating impurities and makeup residues to clean the area of ​​your eyes more effectively and gently.

Its use meets the needs of dry and sensitive skin more

Make-up remover oils, on the other hand, work more effectively to clean waterproof, long-lasting, and thick make-up.

However, be sure to check for allergens, perfumes, and other substances that may irritate your eyelids. It could indeed be that the cleansing oil attacks sensitive or acne-prone skin.

As for cleansing milk, its emollient-based formulation is gentle enough to suit dry and sensitive eyelids. Its hydrating and nourishing formula protects your eyelids from drying out. This cleaner also has great cleaning power.

Aside from micellar water, makeup removing oil, and cleansing milk, eye makeup removers can come in a solid formula.

The advantage with this make-up remover lies in its purifying capacity which greatly exceeds that of the three previous cleansers. This formula is perfect for intense waterproof makeup removal.

As an alternative to these four formulas, note that these makeup removers can be offered in the form of a cleansing gel. In addition to being soft and light, gel eye area makeup removers have a cooling property.

Depending on the quality of the gel, this makeup remover offers greater compatibility in use.

It can therefore also meet the requirements of dry, normal, oily, sensitive, and combination skin. If you are having trouble finding the perfect makeup removal formula for your eyes, consult your dermatologist!

2. The cleansing ability of eye area makeup remover

Not all makeup removers for the eye area provide the same cleaning ability. Some makeup removers remove certain makeup-less effectively than others.

If you are used to wearing light makeup, just using a soft, liquid formula may be more than enough. If not, make sure that the product really allows you to remove your waterproof makeup or mascara without irritating your eyelids!

3. Compatibility of use of the make-up remover when wearing contact lenses

This criterion is essential if you wear contact lenses and in this case, the makeup remover must also have been the subject of ophthalmological approval.

This is a guarantee of safety for your eyes since an inappropriate choice of makeup remover can seriously damage your eyesight.

4. The formulation with or without perfume

The choice of formulation of a makeup remover with or without perfume is not based solely on your preferences.

The presence of perfume in a cleansing lotion can cause skin intolerance reactions in some people with extremely sensitive eyelids. If you have any doubts, it will be better to favor a fragrance-free makeup remover.

5. The conformity of organic makeup remover in relation to ethics and ecology

Most natural eye makeup removers are certified organic and ethical, while others are not. This means on the one hand that the makeup remover in question does not contain any ingredient of animal origin and on the other hand, it has not been tested on any animal.

The compliance of an organic makeup remover with respect to ethics and the environment are two important criteria that you must consider to ensure its good quality.

By purchasing such a product, you will do a positive gesture towards our planet and you will also gain the assurance of a much healthier use.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Can removing makeup from around the eyes present any risks?

It is important that you choose the correct type of makeup remover to avoid the risk of weakening the sensitive area around the eyes.

The residue of mascara or make-up under the crease of the eyelids can cause serious infections or cause them to swell. You will also need to remove make-up from this area gently and more delicately.

  • Are eye makeup removers absolutely essential?

Removing makeup from around the eyes is more delicate than removing make-up from other parts of your face. The ideal would therefore be to buy a specific makeup remover to clean this area, being careful to choose it.

The use of cleansing oil is gentler and more effective. You can also choose the type of oil according to the needs, requirements, and skin sensitivity of your eyelids. It will definitely depend on your skin type.

However, be aware that you can choose between jojoba oil, coconut oil, sweet almond oil, grapeseed oil, and olive oil.

  • What simple tips for successful waterproof makeup removal?

Take a clean, dry cotton swab, then dampen it lightly with lukewarm water! Lightly rub the eye area covered with mascara to clean it on the surface!

Take another clean piece of cotton wool and pour in a small amount of special heavy mascara makeup remover! Clean as you go without rushing, then rinse gently!

  • Which makeup remover to choose to remove waterproof mascara without harming the eyelids?

The best way to successfully remove make-up from the eye area is to use a cleansing oil if your eyelids tend to dry out.

With this type of makeup remover, you won’t need to systematically rub your eyelids. The oil will easily dissolve the mascara and you won’t run the risk of damaging your lashes.

  • What is the best choice of makeup remover oil for your eyes?

Castor oil, olive oil, and argan oil are all beneficial for removing makeup from the eyes. The first will make you look more beautiful. The second will make your daily life easier and the third will offer a real youthful appearance around your eyes.

This review presents you with the best drugstore eye makeup removers for an effortless experience. Read through and find one that suits your budget and needs.

Resources: 1, 2, 3, 4.

Last update on 2021-09-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment